Recruiter Hustle
From recruiter to agency owner: the shifts you have to make to succeed on your own
Chris Allen
Aug 16, 2025
TL;DR
Growing trend of recruiters launching their own agencies to capitalize on increased demand for specialized talent
Developing a business mindset and focusing on growth is crucial for agency owners
Managing finances effectively and making informed investments are key to long-term success
Creating a strong brand and leveraging technology can help agencies stand out in a crowded market
Nurturing relationships and providing value beyond placements are essential for client retention and referrals
Developing leadership skills and prioritizing well-being are critical for agency owners to avoid burnout and maintain productivity
Embracing change and demonstrating adaptability are key to overcoming challenges and seizing opportunities in the dynamic world of talent acquisition
Entrepreneurship is a tantalizing prospect for many individual contributors working for corporate companies. Whether it’s the concept of ownership, the increased share of profits, or the flexible schedule, pursuing entrepreneurship is on the rise with an annual growth rate of 21% (Hostinger).
The recruiting industry is no different. Recruiters working for large firms are noticing the rise in prices for everyday items and the stagnation in salary increases, with many raises not matching inflation.
Yes, recruiter-to-owner is the American Dream manifest. That being said, the journey is not easy. It takes a mindset shift and a hunger to learn on the job. There are major transitions that need to take place. Here are five key steps to go from individual contributor to recruiting agency owner:
Yes, recruiter-to-owner is the American Dream manifest. That being said, the journey is not easy. It takes a mindset shift and a hunger to learn on the job. There are major transitions that need to take place. Here are five key steps to go from individual contributor to recruiting agency owner:
Develop a business mindset
Become financially savvy
Build a recognizable brand
Grow a network of trust
Embrace new technology
Developing a business mindset
There’s a mental shift from recruiter to agency owner, and that shift revolves around growth accountability. Enjoying a career as an individual contributor recruiter involves reporting to a decision-maker. Stepping into the driver’s seat brings on all sorts of decisions that no one else is going to make. The foundation of building a business is making decisions.
Construct a business strategy
Offers, leads, money models (and anything else Alex Hormozi talks about) make up the lifeblood of a business. Without healthy strategic systems in place, the business will fail, or worse, stagnate. If you’re not growing, you’re not keeping up with inflation ($100M Offers by Alex Hormozi). Stagnation is the slow death of a recruitment agency. But it doesn’t have to be.
Find a niche
Generalist is out. Making something for everyone just isn’t a viable business model anymore. To gain market share and better cater to clients, become uber specific with who your recruitment agency serves. For instance, Happlicant, an applicant tracking system (ATS) is built exclusively for solo recruiters and small recruitment agencies. Because of this, they are better equipped to meet the unique needs of small recruiting businesses, such as tight budgets, few employees, and the need to move quickly.
A great niche niches down two or three times. “A recruitment agency” becomes “a recruitment agency for the tech industry.” Or, better yet, “a recruitment agency that finds top AI engineers for B2B SaaS companies.” The more specific your niche, the better you’ll understand the client. And further, the better you’ll understand the client’s needs. Better niche = better service.
Becoming financially savvy
Thriving as a recruiting agency means getting and staying financially secure. Business money management fundamentals can be difficult to learn, but they are an imperative part of building an agency. Stay consistent with learning a little every day, and put your learning into practice the day you learn it. Monitoring cash flow and making informed financial decisions lead to a healthy bottom line. Budget for startup costs and reinvest profits to grow sustainably.
Recruitment agency startup costs
Expenses for startups vary significantly and can range from a few thousand dollars to hundreds of thousands of dollars, depending on the setup. Remote vs in-office plays a significant role in costs, as does staffing and payroll, and software.
Service pricing models also can vary, but typically a full-time placement earns the agency 15–20% of the placement’s first-year salary, with more specialized placements earning fees closer to 30% (LinkedIn).
Long-term profitability sits on the pricing model you decide for the agency. Retainers, fees incurred merely for staying available to a client, are also an option to consider. In addition to expected startup costs, agency owners need to be aware of less-often-considered costs. Compliance, licensing, and other unforeseen expenses should be accounted for in an agency’s budget. We recommend at least a 10–15% buffer to take care of the inevitable unforeseen expenses.
Investing and reinvesting in your agency
Once profits start coming in, reinvest a portion into technology and talent, which can improve operational efficiency and make an agency’s growth scalable. More than 86% of recruiters confirm that their ATS reduces their overall time-to-hire (Select Software Reviews).
Choose an ATS that works with your unique approach to attracting and hiring quality talent. Happlicant software happens to be an incredible investment, providing great value for the tightest of budgets. It’s completely configurable and has features spanning from automation to outreach to job postings and everything in between.
Building a recognizable brand
Marketing and branding attract clients and make your agency recognizable in your niche industry. Don’t skimp on either. Logos and branding packages can be pricey, but working with a professional branding designer is a surefire way to bolster a recruitment agency’s professional appearance.
AI and branding
In the age of AI, it’s tempting to produce AI-driven everything. If you embrace AI, be sure to have a professional marketer or designer sign off on the AI content. Check your logo and agency name with the US Patent and Trademark Office to ensure they can be trademarked at the official USPTO website. Also, be sure to use a domain checker like Instant Domain Search to ensure you can get a good website URL based on your chosen agency name.
Value proposition
In addition to niching down, standing out against competitors becomes easier when an agency creates a compelling value proposition. Emphasizing an industry specialization, a unique talent acquisition method, and/or a high-touch approach can set you apart from other noise in the market.
Online presence
Establish a strong online presence to position your agency as an industry expert. Creating (and consistently maintaining) social media profiles on chosen platforms where your target market already exists. Whether it’s LinkedIn, Reddit, or X, showcase thoughtful content through articles, posts, and webinars. Share insights on hiring trends and challenges facing the industry. This can further enhance agency credibility, building trust amongst your clients and candidates.
Pro tip: Gary Vaynerchuk’s content strategy can be effective for even the smallest of marketing teams. His method involves breaking down intentional long-form content or “pillar content” (keynote speeches, podcasts, and webinars) into short-form content or “micro content” (articles, images, quotes, and videos).
Growing a network of trust
Cultivate trust through transparent, authentic communication and outreach. Recruiting agencies that reach out early and often typically benefit from higher client retention rates, increased referrals, and reduced candidate drop-off rates. Deliver on promises and exceed expectations when possible to establish a reputation of reliability.
Professional authenticity
Along with a logo, a brand needs a voice. That voice can adopt any number of characteristics, like being silly, knowledgeable, friendly, and authentic. Voice can be established in emails, articles, social posts, and other forms of outbound marketing. Keep your agency’s voice consistent, and with time, you’ll increase the agency’s trustworthiness.
Authentic outreach
Whether you’re using an AI-driven or manual outbound marketing approach, seek connection. Focus on building an authentic relationship based on commonality and shared needs. Establish a connection in your first outreach message to a client or candidate. “Hi Ellen, your recent foray into startup culture reminded me of my early days as an entrepreneur.” Then continue the conversation before introducing the sale.
Provide unreasonable value
As a recruiting agency, it is expected that you provide placements; however, ongoing support and communication with clients and candidates alike will set you apart as a recruiting agency that cares about going the extra mile.
Check in on clients and candidates often to provide updates. Air on the side of providing boringly clear communication with frequency. Don’t let your candidates wonder where they stand, and don’t let you clients think you went radio silent.
Position your agency as a trusted source of advisors and partners. It’s expensive to attract new clients. Keeping the ones you’ve won saves money and increases customer lifetime value (CLV). Ask for referrals. Don’t leave them up to chance. Support without asking, and then ask if you can do anything further to improve the client experience. In doing. so, you will foster long-lasting. relationships that are mutually beneficial.
Support employees
Being an agency owner, generally means having staff and other talent to manage. Don’t be scared to help individual contributors stay marketable. If you treat talent well, offer frequent training, and pay them fairly (or even a little more than fairly), you can reduce churn of employees and focus on hiring for clients instead of yourself.
Get access to the fastest-growing agency & independent recruiter software. CRM, ATS and much more to run and grow your business more efficiently.
Embracing new technology
Automation, AI, and other digital innovations can reduce time spent on repetitive tasks, keeping you focused on cultivating relationships and other high-touch endeavors.
ATS software and other tech
Digital hiring tech has replaced outdated spreadsheets for several reasons, namely:
scalability
efficiency
professionalism
As far as a recruiting agency’s tech stack, it typically includes an ATS, a customer relationship manager (CRM), marketing automation tools, and an analytics platform. Of course, Happlicant meets all four needs, letting agencies balance candidates, clients, marketing, and metrics all in one platform, delivering great value and world-class usability for even the tightest of budgets.
Choosing the right ATS for your agency can be overwhelming, but it doesn’t have to be. Learn about how Happlicant can meet your growing agency’s needs at Happlicant's website.
Regardless of which ATS you pick, continue to explore and adopt new tools that maximize your return on investment (ROI) and grow your small business. Staying ahead of technology trends helps recruitment agencies stay competitive in a highly saturated market.
Extra pro tips
While developing a business mindset, becoming financially savvy, building a recognizable brand, growing a network of trust, and embracing new technology can lead you to success, here is some bonus advice to stay successful.
Set boundaries
Burnout in recruitment agency owners is real. One way to avoid burnout is through setting boundaries. Working long hours can lead to burnout, as can a blurred sense of work/life balance. When you checkout of work at the end of the workday, be sure to actually checkout. Turn off regular work-related email and messaging apps. Minimize worry by providing a line where clients can reach you in case of emergencies, but keep every other line of communication on do not disturb.
Scope creep can cause stress as well. Be sure to write out the expected service you will provide in the client contract. If the client wants to change the scope of the contract, be helpful and provide pricing options that would make the extra work worth it.
Manage time effectively
Consider time management tools and systems that will keep yourself organized. Find what works for you, whether that’s a digital process or a manual process that gets digitized. Don’t risk loosing the only hard copy of your calendar. Keep a single digital source of truth.
Reserve your most productive hours for larger tasks. Many people find themselves to be most productive when they first wake up. Establish a morning routine that sets yourself up for success. Fuel your body with food and water, and don’t start the day with distracting emails or social updates.
Invest in self-care
Outside of work, invest your time into channels that fill your proverbial cup. Regain your energy from resting and allowing yourself to be unproductive. Recovering from stress can be…stressful. But, again, setting a routine can help.
After work, create a checking out ritual. Drinking tea or going for a walk can be a great way to signal to your body that it’s time to stop working. Spend time with loved ones and don’t neglect relationships that bring you joy.
Closing thoughts
Entrepreneurship is a tantalizing prospect for many individual contributors working for corporate companies. If you’re looking to make the leap to recruiting agency owner, a change in mindset must occur. Grow skills that will aid in your business’s success. Don’t back down from a challenge just because it’s hard. You can do hard things.
At the same time, be calculated and thorough. Construct a business strategy. Find your niche. Manage startup costs and reinvest in the business. Establish a brand and build a unique value proposition. Cultivate an online presence. Be professional. Be authentic in your communication. Provide unreasonable value. Support employees. Embrace technology by choosing the right ATS. And above all, take care of yourself. Set boundaries, manage time effectively, and invest in self-care.
See Happlicant's software in action
Jump on a quick demo call to see how Happlicant's ATS/CRM can save you time and help you grow your agency.
